Can you fix prisons without abolishing them?: Reformers
New to criminal justice reform
The seminary on the tier
Warden Burl Cain arrived at Angola — 18,000 acres of former plantation land, the highest inmate-on-inmate violence rate in the country — in 1995. By 2005, violent incidents had dropped seventy-three percent. He did not hire more guards. He brought in a seminary. Lifers enrolled, graduated, became chaplains on tiers where they once carried shanks. The program did not make Angola good. It made Angola survivable, which in American corrections is a revolution.
We have run tiers. We have watched men change — slowly, incompletely, in ways that do not photograph well. The abolitionists tell us the cage is the problem. We have worked inside the cage. Removing it without building something in its place is a different problem.
Norway spends $129,000 per inmate per year on education, vocational training, mental health. The US spends $35,000 on concrete and razor wire — and gets recidivism rates nearly triple Norway’s. The RAND Corporation found every dollar on prison education saves four to five in reincarceration. The return is not debatable. The political will is what is missing.
We built a Norwegian-model unit inside Texas. Residents have keys, cook meals, attend classes. Recidivism dropped below twenty percent against a statewide average above forty-three. The program runs in a state that would never call itself reformist. It works anyway, because the evidence is overwhelming.
The restorative justice practitioners are our natural allies. Circles inside facilities reduce disciplinary infractions and post-release offending. We consider restorative justice the missing center of incarceration.
Where we concede ground: We have been reforming prisons for a century and the system is worse. Reform being absorbed by the machine is a pattern.
What would change our mind: Five states implement evidence-based reform fully, and after twenty years the reforms are systematically gutted back to baseline.
Read the full synthesis: Can you fix prisons without abolishing them?