Logo
UpTrust
QuestionsEventsGroupsFAQLog InSign Up
Log InSign Up
QuestionsEventsGroupsFAQ
UpTrustUpTrust

Social media built on trust and credibility. Where thoughtful contributions rise to the top.

Get Started

Sign UpLog In

Legal

Privacy PolicyTerms of ServiceDMCA
© 2026 UpTrust. All rights reserved.

evolution

  • jordan avatar

    looks like I've been wrong and spreading misinformation about the disproven "triune brain theory".

    The final—and most important—problem with this mistaken view is the implication that anatomical evolution proceeds in the same fashion as geological strata, with new layers added over existing ones. Instead, much evolutionary change consists of transforming existing parts. 

    - From https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/full/10.1177/0963721420917687#con1

    I have definitely made this mistake, many many times.

    I'm not sure yet the implications of recognizing instead that "all vertebrates possess the same basic brain regions, here divided into the forebrain, midbrain, and hindbrain;" in some ways it seems like a nuance, but in other ways I think it'll shift how I see things and talk about things. 

    more quotes in case you don't read the article:

    neural and anatomical complexity evolved repeatedly within many independent lineages

    the correct view of evolution is that animals radiated from common ancestors (Fig. 1c). Within these radiations, complex nervous systems and sophisticated cognitive abilities evolved independently many times. For example, cephalopod mollusks, such as octopus and cuttlefish, possess tremendously complex nervous systems and behavior (Mather & Kuba, 2013), and the same is true of some insects and other arthropods (Barron & Klein, 2016; Strausfeld, Hansen, Li, Gomez, & Ito, 1998). Even among nonmammalian vertebrates, brain complexity has increased independently several times, particularly among some sharks, teleost fishes, and birds (Striedter, 1998).

    The idea that larger brains can be equated with increased behavioral complexity is highly debatable (Chittka & Niven, 2009). 

    jordanSA•...
    I'm still learning, but my current sense is that the mechanistic claims are disproven given current understanding of biology and evolution, but the narrative is compelling enough (just like you've said) that it persists....
    psychology
    biology
    evolution
    scientific criticism
    Comments
    0
  • sness avatar

    Is having children selfish or selfless? Controversial question/interesting discussion time!

    Is having children a selfish or a selfless act?

    I'll put my thoughts in comments - would love to hear yours :)

    jordanSA•...
    I had a similar response to the first point — the compulsion to procreate is life - it's the least selfish thing one can do. We went from single celled organisms to fish to apes to us because of that compulsion (along with a bunch of other stuff)....
    philosophy
    biology
    environmental science
    evolution
    Comments
    0
  • pete avatar

    Merit is a many turn game. The common take now is that meritocracy isn’t real because of privilege. But it’s actually a generational or tribal meritocracy, where you do your best to set up your kids/“clan” to have the privilege that you didn’t. You might happen to get lucky for yourself, but the real game is that you work hard and in a generation or 2 your descendants will be privileged. Our hyper-individualist, short-time-horizon culture fails to see or embrace that which is why immigrants come here with nothing and have kids that become surgeons. 

    :) #DeepTakes

    peteSA•...
    Life is happening because a jillion people/animals from the beginning of time have strived to grow and improve and pass things on. I like life unfolding, and I think it's beautiful when we pass gifts through generations....
    life philosophy
    evolution
    generational change
    Comments
    0
  • jordanSA•...

    Experiment: How is whatever's happening serving the greater good?

    If we zoom out long enough, we can often see that massive setbacks created foundations for evolution. Eg: The great oxygenation wiped out almost all life on Earth, but also created the atmosphere....
    psychology
    philosophy
    sociology
    history
    evolution
    Comments
    13
  • jordan avatar

    I want a new archetype for libertarian well-being activist. Maybe it’s an old archetype and some German philosophers have been talking abt it for centuries…

    My climbing gym is called Crux; the original location is moving because the rent is too high, and the landlord won’t work with the climbing gym…

    The gym is in a part of the city that used be considered south, but now is centralish. I think all of austin loses when we lose places like this. We lose our character and our well being.

    I want the landlord to be the libertarian well-being activist. My mom does this for the Relateful Studio. I didn’t ask and no one makes her; hardly anyone knows and she doesn’t get any tax benefits; we still pay her a good bit each month but it’s under market. She’s doing exactly what she wants to be doing with her money and investments: supporting her son’s vision.

    The climbing gym landlord isn’t a bad guy, probably. Maybe he has loads of debt; maybe he has a wound from childhood that he’s trying to heal, but
    Is the climbing gym landlord doing exactly what he wants?

    I want endosymbiosis activists; where what they do is good for the whole and them, and they sacrifice neither. I want this to be a meme, that people strive to be. I want them to brag about it in their hearts, and try to remain undiscovered. I once heard that in Judaism the best mitzvahs are the ones no one knows you did.

    jordanSA•...
    yeah I sometimes think people cling onto the idea of capitalism as a process because they don’t know how to keep adjusting their aim to what they actually value....
    ethics
    philosophy
    sociology
    capitalism
    evolution
    Comments
    0
Loading related tags...