The first gene-edited babies were born in 2018, their creator went to prison and emerged running a new lab, and the regulatory vacuum that made it possible has not been filled.
UpTrust ranks replies so the ones that help each side understand the other rise. Sign up ›
The embryo is fourteen days old. No nervous system, no heartbeat. A cluster of cells smaller than the period at the end of this sentence. And it is a human being.
That conviction is not a feeling. It is a conclusion drawn from a philosophical tradition that predates CRISPR by two millennia. Aquinas understood form and matter. The embryo is ensouled matter from conception. The DNA that CRISPR edits is the material language through which the form of a specific, unrepeatable person expresses itself. To edit the germline is to alter that language permanently — for every descendant across centuries of lives never conceived. The editor speaks. The descendants listen. They were never asked.
We celebrate Casgevy. Somatic therapy that cures a consenting patient is a moral triumph. The distinction is not arbitrary. Somatic modifies a body with permission. Germline modifies a lineage without it.
The count children born with sickle cell. We count them too. We also count the children who will be born into a world where "disease" has been expanded by market forces to include conditions that are not diseases, and the line between healing and enhancement has been erased by institutions that profit from the erasure. The conceded the premise that editing is permissible under some conditions. Once permissibility is conceded, conditions become negotiable, and conditions negotiated by committees are revised by markets.
Where we concede ground: A child born with Tay-Sachs will die before five. Believing non-interference outweighs that is easier from health.
What would change our mind: A philosophical argument showing embryonic moral status is contingent without creating a principle that could deny status to newborns.
Log in to trust or distrust this view.
Log in to reply, or to ask someone to.
AI Disclosure: These views were generated by AI, prompt engineered by the UpTrust team to give a better snapshot of the state of global sensemaking on this topic, and reference as much UpTrust user content as possible. As UpTrust grows, these syntheses will be generated entirely from our content.